Avatar of admin


The Stupidity of the American Voter

November 14, 2014 in Economics

By Jim Harper

Jim Harper

Conservatives and libertarians were scandalized this week to see video of MIT economist and Obamacare “architect” Jonathan Gruber describing how a lack of transparency allowed the president’s signature health care regulation to pass. The real scandal would be if Republicans, now in control of both the House and Senate, allowed the conditions that produced Obamacare to persist.

Pro-transparency changes in the 114th Congress could create a bulwark against legislation of any stripe being rammed through with insufficient public oversight, debate, and consensus. The Obama administration is already committed to greater transparency in executive branch spending, as it implements a bill passed last spring called the DATA Act.

“Lack of transparency is a huge political advantage,” academic economist Gruber said at a conference last year, singing like a canary about the Obamacare debate. “And basically — y’know, call it the stupidity of the American voter or whatever — but basically that was really, really critical to get the thing to pass.”

Debates about future legislation and programs should be won or lost on something closer to the merits, not on non-transparent shenanigans.”

Obamacare’s backers may see Gruber’s words as a little too transparent themselves, but he was almost certainly right. Greater public knowledge of both the process and Obamacare’s inner workings, which are clearly deficient, would have produced a better debate and a better outcome.

If there’s “stupidity” among American voters, it’s the product of all the information they’re not given. Congress gave a nod to the Internet and transparency when it established the Thomas web site at the beginning of the 104th Congress in 1995. And Congress.gov is a recent user-friendly improvement. But documents and records in HTML and PDF hardly meet the public’s need for information. Twenty years on, the most recent Republican-landslide Congress should advance the ball on transparency again, by producing information about its activities as computer-readable data, in real time.

It would be impossible to catalog all the data Congress should share with the public. The House has been making slow and steady advances, including the creation of document-and-data repository docs.house.gov. But one area that is particularly ripe for improvement is legislation.

The bills introduced in Congress are published in a technical format called XML that readies them for printing and web display. That same format can be used to make bills at least partially computer-readable. The Cato Institute’s “Deepbills” project does exactly that. Supported by the …read more

Source: OP-EDS

Leave a reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.